Skip to main content
Rims & Tires

Buyer guide · 4 min read

AWD and 4WD: Can You Replace Just One Tire? Allowed Tread Difference

Published by Rims & Tires

Compiled by Rims & Tires from manufacturer, government & industry sources · Updated 2026-10-23

Sometimes, but check your manual first. None of the owner's manuals cited here gives a number for how much tread difference an AWD vehicle allows. Subaru says all four tires must match, down to circumference and degree of wear. Honda says it's best to replace all four. The usual workaround is tire shaving, about $25 to $35 a tire at Tire Rack, according to Consumer Reports.

Why tread difference matters on AWD

Consumer Reports explains the mechanics: a tire's circumference gets smaller as the tread wears, so a worn tire rotates faster than a new one. Nissan's Rogue manual describes an AWD High Temp warning that appears when the difference in rotation between the front and rear wheels is large, and the system then drops to 2WD to protect the powertrain. Subaru's manual goes further and warns that tires that differ in circumference, among other things, could cause serious mechanical damage to the drivetrain.

Our replace all 4 tires guide covers the general case. This page is about the AWD tolerance question.

What the automakers say

The table below quotes what each maker's own text says. Subaru is the strictest. Its 2025 Outback manual (the Subaru Europe edition) lists eight things that must match across all four tires, including circumference and degree of wear, and says it recommends replacing all four at the same time. Nissan's 2024 Rogue has a Tire Size Incorrect warning that tells you to check that sizes, brand, construction, and tread pattern match and that the tires are not excessively worn. Honda says it is best to replace all four, and pairs if you can't.

The manuals cited here cover AWD cars and crossovers. Part-time 4WD trucks can behave differently, so check your own manual and ask the dealer.

West Georgia Local

Find the right shop near you

Tell us your vehicle and what you need — we'll match you with a vetted West Georgia shop. Free, no obligation.

The tolerance numbers you see online

You'll see rules like a maximum of 2/32 or 3/32 difference between tires. No owner's manual cited here gives a figure like that, so none is given. The honest source is your owner's manual or your dealer's service department. Ask them for the number for your exact model, and ask them to put it in writing if a warranty is at stake.

Tire shaving

Shaving removes tread from a new tire so it matches your worn ones. Consumer Reports says you can buy a tire from Tire Rack and have it shaved to match, usually for $25 to $35, and that other retailers may offer it though the equipment isn't common. It says shaving makes the most sense when your other tires are no more than about half worn, roughly 6/32 left, and that shaving will likely nullify the new tire's treadwear warranty.

Measure all four tires with a gauge first (see the tread depth chart). If the other three are close to the wear bars, shaving saves little and a full set is the better value. If one tire is ruined and the rest are nearly new, shaving is worth a call to a local shop that has the equipment. Our mixing brands guide covers matching the model.

Your options when one tire is damaged

First, measure all four tires in the same groove. If the three good tires are close to the wear bars, replacing all four is the simple answer, and it is what Subaru and Honda recommend anyway. If the three are nearly new, check whether the shop can match the new tire to the same model and size, which our mixing brands guide explains.

If the three are somewhere in the middle, that is where shaving earns its keep. Ask the shop three questions: do you shave tires or can you send the tire out, what will the new tire's final tread depth be, and what does the maker say about the warranty afterward. Then check the answer against your owner's manual, because the manual is what your dealer will point to.

Sources

Subaru Europe, 2025 Outback owner's manual, tires section: https://www.subaru.eu/docs/default-source/owner's-manuals/outback-2025/vehicle/25my-outback-english-vehicle-owner's-manual.pdf

Nissan USA, 2024 Rogue owner's manual: https://www.nissanusa.com/content/dam/Nissan/us/manuals-and-guides/rogue/2024/2024-nissan-rogue-owner-manual.pdf

Honda, 2024 CR-V owner's manual, Tire and Wheel Replacement: https://techinfo.honda.com/rjanisis/pubs/om/ah/a3a02424iom/enu/details/131240047-14857.html

Mercedes-Benz USA, G-Class 2025 owner's manual: https://www.mbusa.com/en/owners/manuals/g-class-suv-2025-03-e465-mbux/changing-a-wheel/notes-on-selecting-assembling-and-replacing-tires

BFGoodrich and Nitto, in the Toyota Tire Warranty Guide: https://assets.sipb.toyota.com/publications/en/omms-s/TL-MMS-20Tire/pdf/TL-MMS-20Tire.pdf

Consumer Reports, Do You Really Need to Replace All Four Tires on an AWD Car: https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/tires/tire-shaving-awd-car-no-need-to-replace-all-four-tires-a4235415952/

Last checked 2026-10-23. We are not tire experts, and this is not professional advice. Your owner's manual rules.

What each maker's own text says about replacing tires on AWD vehicles

Maker and sourceWhat the text says (no tread-depth number in any of them)
Subaru, 2025 Outback manual (Europe edition)All four tires must be the same in manufacturer, brand (tread pattern), construction, and size. Items to match: size, speed symbol, load index, circumference, construction, manufacturer, brand, and degrees of wear. Recommends replacing all four at the same time.
Nissan, 2024 Rogue manualTire Size Incorrect warning: check that tire sizes, brand, construction, and tread pattern are the same and that the tires are not excessively worn. Replacement: same size, tread design, speed rating, and load capacity as original.
Honda, 2024 CR-V manualIt is best to replace all four tires at the same time. If that isn't possible, replace the front or rear tires in pairs.
Mercedes-Benz, 2025 G-Class manualUse tires and wheels of the same type and the same manufacture, and the same wheel size on one axle.
BFGoodrich (Toyota tire guide)Same size and type on all four wheel positions. Check the vehicle owner's manual before mixing.
Nitto (Toyota tire guide)Recommends all four tires be the same size, speed rating, and construction.

Frequently asked

Can I replace just one tire on my AWD vehicle?

Maybe. Subaru's manual says all four tires must match in circumference and wear, and Honda says it is best to replace all four. Replacing one is possible if the other three are nearly new or you have the new tire shaved to match. Check your owner's manual.

How much tread difference is allowed on AWD?

No owner's manual cited here gives a number, so none is given. Ask your dealer's service department for the figure for your model.

What is tire shaving and how much does it cost?

Shaving removes tread from a new tire to match your worn ones. Consumer Reports says Tire Rack does it for usually $25 to $35 per tire on tires bought from it, and other shops may offer it too.

Does tire shaving void the tire warranty?

Consumer Reports says it will likely nullify the tire's treadwear warranty. Ask the shop before you shave.

Does this apply to 4WD trucks?

We only read AWD manuals. Part-time 4WD systems may have different rules, so check your owner's manual and ask the dealer before mixing worn and new tires.

Last updated 2026-10-23. General guidance only — confirm specifics with a local shop for your exact vehicle.

Get matched with the right shop

Tell us what you drive and what you want — we point you to the right rim & tire shop near you. Free.